Intolerance debate: What Chief Justice TS Thakur said, and
how media interpreted him Chief
Justice of India TS Thakur, on Sunday weighed in on the debate over intolerance
that has generated huge amount of heat and attention of late.Let's look at what
he actually said.While talking to journalists at his residence two days after
assuming office as the 43rd Chief Justice of India, Thakur said: "Yeh siyasi
pahlu hain(this is a
political issue). We have a rule of law. So long as rule of law is there,
so long as there is an independent judiciary and so long as courts are
upholding the rights and obligations, I do not think anyone has to fear for
anything."On the political aspect of the debate,the CJI said: "Siyasi log
iska kaise upyog karten hain aur kaise fayada uthayenge,
rgb(51, 51, 51); font-family: Arial, sans-serif; text-align: justify; outline: 0px;">main kuchch nahin kehna chahunga(I do not want to say anything on how
politicians use this and try to take advantage of it), but we are committed to
uphold the rule of law and protect the rights of all citizens."He further
said, "India is a big country, we should not be afraid of anything. Yeh
sab perception ki batein hain. Jab tak judiciary independent hai,koi baat ki
dar nahi honi chahiye (These are all matters of perception. There is nothing to
fear till the judiciary is independent).""We are committed to uphold
the Rule of Law and protect right of all citizens of the society and people
from all creeds and religions. There is no fear to any section of
society," Chief Justice Thakur added.This was a clear, authoritative,
unequivocal statement from Indian judiciary's highest chair. The CJI has taken
a stand, reinforced faith in India's democratic institutions and allayed fear
of its citizens. Let's now take a look at how the media chose to interpret
the CJI's statement.The following are the headlines from some English language
newspapers in India and some websites who reported on the event:The Indian Express, which
was at the forefront of the 'intolerance' debate, carried this headline in its
Delhi edition: "Tolerance must…no need to fear as long as judiciary is
there: new CJI"